Baseball continues to see fewer black players
Fighting socio-economic factors, baseball unable to reverse decline of African-Americans in majors
07/17/2011 12:09 AM
11/12/2014 2:24 PM
Yankees center fielder Curtis Granderson moved to the top dugout step, looked into the stands of Rangers Ballpark and challenged his teammates.
"Count the number of African-American people here at the stadium who aren't working at the stadium and see if you can get to 10," Granderson said.
A teammate will point at a black man only to hear Granderson reject it because, "He's Latin." Or, "You already counted him."
"At first, it starts off as a joke," Granderson said. "And then as the game moves on, you'll get to 10, or maybe 15. Depends on where you are, too. Places like Chicago or New York, other places, it's easy. Here, it's hard. So after a while it becomes, 'Told you so.' "
When Jackie Robinson broke baseball's racial barrier in 1947 it was a watershed moment for blacks, America and baseball. Sixty-four years later, the numbers suggest African-Americans don't care much about playing the sport anymore.
"Twenty years ago I had three or four black teammates," veteran Rangers pitcher Darren Oliver said. "Now, it's one or two."
For a variety of reasons, from societal to financial, the sport can't seem to reverse the trend of fewer African-Americans playing baseball.
The University of Central Florida's Institute for Diversity and Ethics in Sports reported this year that the number of blacks in baseball is down to 8.5 percent. The percentage of Latinos is 27 percent.
The percentage for African-Americans in MLB is at its lowest level since 2007. When the institute began to track the figure in 1990, 17 percent of all MLB players were African-American. Beginning in 1997, the number has steadily decreased for a variety of reasons.
When Cory Patterson walks into the Toronto Blue Jays' clubhouse before a game he sees his teammates and his friends. People he enjoys playing the game with. What he doesn't see are very many people who look like him.
He is one of three black players on his roster.
"I really do like all of my teammates and I'm friends with them," Patterson said. "But it does bother me. It does. I'm not saying the whole stadium needs to be brown or black, it's not that. I could talk about this until I'm blue in the face, and you might sympathize, but it doesn't affect you, so you don't think about it too long.
"My mental processes might be different because of the environment I'm in.
"It's hard for me to explain. Someone might say it's fine and we're all cool, but it's easier said if you're the majority."
Blacks have never been close to the majority in baseball. But in the NBA, the number of African-American players is over 80 percent. In the NFL, it's over 60 percent.
"If you poll a lot of African-American guys that are between 20 and 40 years old [about] what NBA player did you watch and want to be, they're all going to say Jordan," Granderson said. "He was the best player and he looked like us. Baseball, you have a group of players that are playing right now who could say Ken Griffey Jr., but he's no longer in the game, and there hasn't been anybody to replace him."
On Wednesday, TCU baseball coach Jim Schlossnagle was running his annual baseball camp for youngsters 6 to 14. He estimated that out of 200 campers, there were between five and 10 African-Americans.
In 2010, only nine African-Americans were on the rosters of the 13 Division I college baseball programs in Texas.
"We all get along, but sometimes you look around and you don't see someone that looks like you," Patterson said. "It's kind of tough some days. It's nothing against my teammates. It's something you don't think about unless you experience it."
Schlossnagle said a good baseball bat costs between $300 and $400.
"That's just the bat, a good one -- the one you would want to swing," he said. "Then there is the other equipment, too. And now that youth baseball has become all about traveling teams, select teams, and those are expensive for whites or African-Americans. Obviously not every African-American is without financial resources, but in my opinion at the amateur level our sport has become a white-collar sport," Schlossnagle said. "Doesn't mean it's a white sport, but it does mean that it's expensive to play."
The median income of African-American households was $32,584 in 2009, according to the Census Bureau, below the U.S. median of $49,777.
As far as Granderson is concerned, the price tag on baseball is helping drive the number of African-Americans away as much as anything else.
Paul Friedman of Burleson has been involved with select baseball for the past six years, and serves as the secretary for Pony Elite Baseball. He and his friends tried to come up with a youth league for something far less than what is normally charged. He estimates that most select youth baseball teams charge around $3,000 per player for a season.
"Cost has definitely eroded the sport," Friedman said. "Most teams are predominately white. It's sort of like hockey -- most people who get involved in that sport, they know it's expensive. Baseball is not that far off."
It's not the cost of playing today, but the cost of down the road as well.
Some youngsters might pick a sport based on the potential college scholarship if they're good enough. Twenty years ago, NCAA rules allowed for 20 baseball scholarships in Division I. Then the number was reduced to 13, and then it was chopped again to 11.7.
Seldom does a college baseball player receive anything more than 50 percent, and scholarships usually go to pitchers.
A football or basketball scholarship is a full ride in Division I.
"When Dontrelle Willis was coming out of high school he had a 90 percent offer from Pepperdine, and he still couldn't do it," Granderson said. "That happens all over the place."
Because of this, Granderson said, he had people leaning on him to just drop baseball and focus on basketball.
Marketing the game
When Granderson was a kid playing baseball he would often hear that he was "playing the white man's sport."
Granderson, Patterson, Oliver and others believe one of the problems is the lack of marketing toward the African-American community, which creates an image that baseball is still the white man's game.
Granderson, who played six seasons for Detroit, specifically mentioned Tigers advertising billboards in African-American communities that featured the white players on the team. And this was a roster that at the time had Granderson, Gary Sheffield, Jacque Jones and other African-Americans.
"Of all the places, Detroit, you'd think that would be the one place where you could market toward African-Americans," he said.
Patterson said he sees a limited effort to spread the word about the African-American players who are playing today. Whether it's Ryan Howard, Prince Fielder or Carl Crawford, there are several All-Star-caliber African-American players who are not always household names.
"I think they promote football and basketball better than baseball, especially with the black folks," Oliver said.
Major League Baseball has tried, for years, to build a grass-roots campaign among young African-Americans with its RBI program. It has been around for 22 years, and it has 300 leagues nationwide, with roughly 200,000 kids ages 5 to 18 playing. That's an increase from 171,000 last season, which was its highest figure to date.
The program has produced 185 players selected in the MLB draft, among them Crawford, CC Sabathia and Jimmy Rollins.
But for some reason those numbers aren't translating to the highest level the sport offers.
"I knew the number was dropping and I'd like to see more African-Americans playing and more kids growing up playing baseball," Rangers reliever Arthur Rhodes said. "I'd like to see more of them come to the games."
As far as Granderson sees this issue, there is only so much that can be done. Even the best programs can't force a pre-teen to play ball if he really doesn't want to.
"I know it's expensive, but I've gone to places and there are fields," he said. "You can easily get equipment donated. I don't know how you fight this one. I've heard a lot of kids just say, 'I don't want to.' That's not a black/white thing, that's a kid thing. So they play on their computer, and they say, 'I want to just stay right where I am. I'm not getting into any trouble so you can't force me.'"
TCU wide receiver Skye Dawson said he played baseball as a fourth-grader. Even though his father played for the Oakland A's organization, he gave up the sport.
"I just didn't find it interesting at all," Dawson said. "I don't watch it now, either. Maybe except for a couple of highlights."
As a result, when Granderson walks to the top of the dugout in Arlington or one in any number of major league cities, he can easily count how few faces look just like his.
Join the Discussion
Fort Worth Star-Telegram is pleased to provide this opportunity to share information, experiences and observations about what's in the news. Some of the comments may be reprinted elsewhere on the site or in the newspaper. We encourage lively, open debate on the issues of the day, and ask that you refrain from profanity, hate speech, personal comments and remarks that are off point. Thank you for taking the time to offer your thoughts.