National

The charges against anti-Planned Parenthood filmmaker, explained

This Oct. 22, 2015, photo shows a Planned Parenthood in Houston. A grand jury investigating undercover footage of Planned Parenthood found no wrongdoing Monday, Jan. 25, 2016, by the abortion provider, and instead indicted anti-abortion activists involved in making the videos that targeted the handling of fetal tissue in clinics and provoked outrage among Republican leaders nationwide. The footage from the clinic in Houston.
This Oct. 22, 2015, photo shows a Planned Parenthood in Houston. A grand jury investigating undercover footage of Planned Parenthood found no wrongdoing Monday, Jan. 25, 2016, by the abortion provider, and instead indicted anti-abortion activists involved in making the videos that targeted the handling of fetal tissue in clinics and provoked outrage among Republican leaders nationwide. The footage from the clinic in Houston. AP

In a surprise move, Texas authorities leveled criminal charges against the anti-abortion activists behind a series of undercover videos targeting Planned Parenthood, which sparked fiery debate last year across the country and on Capitol Hill.

Harris County District Attorney Devon Anderson said David Daleiden, the director of the Center for Medical Progress, faces a felony charge of tampering with a governmental record and a misdemeanor count related to buying human tissue.

Sandra Merritt, one of his employees, was also indicted on a charge of tampering with a governmental record. Arrest warrants have been issued for activists, with a bond amount of $10,000. They can be arrested in any state.

The grand jury, meanwhile, cleared Planned Parenthood Gulf Coast of any wrongdoing.

By way of background, Daleiden's team posed as biomedical employees and wore body cameras to secretly shoot video of Planned Parenthood clinics and employees. They recorded officials discussing the logistics of donating fetal tissue from abortions to researchers, who use human organs to develop new medications.

Daleiden claimed the footage proved Planned Parenthood was illegally selling fetal tissue for profit - a charge the organization has denied. While Planned Parenthood has apologized for the casual tone its employees took in the videos, the organization said it will continue to donate tissue to scientists. It will no longer, however, collect fees to cover the cost of transfering the tissue, which ranges between $25 to $50 per donation.

Initially, the grand jury set out to investigate Planned Parenthood. But on Monday, it instead returned charges against Daleiden. Harris County prosecutors declined to explain the charges. But Josh Schaffer, a lawyer for Planned Parenthood in Houston, took a stab at it. Here's what he says it all means:

Charge: Tampering with a governmental record

Daleiden has admitted to putting together a fake company he dubbed Biomax Procurement Services. His group assumed aliases and claimed to provide fetal tissue to researchers.

The fake IDs used by Daleiden and Merritt, which look like California licenses, triggered the felony charge, said Schaffer. The IDs appeared in Harris County court documents. Daleiden went by Robert Sarkis. Merritt operated under the name Susan Tennenbaum.

They used the cards to get into a Planned Parenthood center in Houston, Schaffer said, which prompted state officials to open an investigation into the clinic after the video was released in August.

"They presented those to security at the Planned Parenthood office to gain access to the facility for the meeting they'd scheduled with the intent to defraud or harm Planned Parenthood," he said. "They secretly videotaped meetings and edited the tapes to be taken out of context."

Intent to cause harm is what elevated the possession of fake IDs to a more serious felony charge than, say, a 16-year-old trying to buy a six-pack would receive, Schaffer said. Under Texas law, the charge carries a penalty of between 2 and 20 years in prison.

Charge: Attempting to buy human tissue

Using his false identity, Daleiden emailed Planned Parenthood in June 2015, asking to buy fetal tissue for $1,600, Schaffer said.

The email was included in court evidence, the lawyer said, but cannot be released to the public during an active case. Whether or not Daleiden actually intended to buy tissue doesn't matter in the eyes of Texas law. The inquiry alone could have spurred the misdemeanor charge.

Authorities don't need to see evidence of a deal or interest from another party to pursue the charge. Planned Parenthood, Schaffer said, never responded to Daleiden's email.

"He probably didn't know he was breaking the law," Schaffer added.

The charge is a misdemeanor, which carries a penalty of up to one year in county jail.

Shortly after the charges were announced, Steve Ertelt, the editor of LifeNews.com, sent out a petition asking people to "help David Daleiden."

"Instead of prosecuting Planned Parenthood for selling aborted baby parts, Daleiden was indicted for buying them," he wrote. "If convicted, Daleiden faces 20 years in prison while Planned Parenthood officials face no legal consequences for their actions."

In a Monday evening statement, the Center for Medical Progress said it "uses the same undercover techniques that investigative journalists have used for decades in exercising our First Amendment rights to freedom of speech and of the press, and follows all applicable laws. We respect the processes of the Harris County District Attorney, and note that buying fetal tissue requires a seller as well. Planned Parenthood still cannot deny the admissions from their leadership about fetal organ sales captured on video for all the world to see."

Planned Parenthood applauded the grand jury's decision and said Daleiden's work used deceptive edits to unfairly implicate them in a crime.

"These anti-abortion extremists spent three years creating a fake company, creating fake identities, lying, and breaking the law," said Eric Ferrero, vice president of communications for Planned Parenthood Federation of America. "When they couldn't find any improper or illegal activity, they made it up."

The videos reinvigorated the debate over the use of fetal tissue procured through abortions and became the subject of a Republican-led investigation into Planned Parenthood on Capitol Hill. Republican presidential candidates have also seized on the footage, calling for Congress to defund the organization, while Democratic contenders argue women's health and access to abortion should be protected.

Several other states - including Florida, Indiana, Missouri and Washington - have done the same, though none had previously sought criminal charges against the creators of the viral videos, which garnered millions of views and provided fodder for Republicans who oppose abortion.

None of the 11 states that opened investigations after the videos were released have found evidence of criminal activity.

This story was originally published January 26, 2016 at 2:10 PM with the headline "The charges against anti-Planned Parenthood filmmaker, explained."

Get unlimited digital access
#ReadLocal

Try 1 month for $1

CLAIM OFFER