Jury ponders sentence for murder suspect guilty of shooting Arlington police officer

Jordan Miles

Akua Smith, the mother of a Saginaw teen shot dead by a man a Tarrant County jury convicted for shooting an Arlington police officer tells why she feels probation is not an appropriate punishment.
Up Next
Akua Smith, the mother of a Saginaw teen shot dead by a man a Tarrant County jury convicted for shooting an Arlington police officer tells why she feels probation is not an appropriate punishment.

Jurors began deliberations Tuesday in the case of a murder suspect convicted of wounding a police officer.

Joel Conner McCommon, a 26-year-old former senior math major at the University of Texas at Arlington, was wounded during an exchange of gunfire with police officers who were trying to arrest him in the murder of Jordan Miles.

Eddie Johnston, the Arlington police officer McCommon wounded, testified Tuesday that the first thought that went through his mind after he got shot was that his wife was going to kill him.

Had the bullet fired by the defendant traveled an inch in another direction, it would have hit a major artery and his circumstances would have been much worse, Johnston said.

Investigators later discovered that the bullet first struck his Taser and his gun belt before lodging in his hip, Johnston said.

“My wife had to see victims assistance to learn how to explain to a 4- and a 6-year-old that their dad had been shot,” Johnston said. “Every day before I leave for work my 6-year-old tells me, ‘Dad, don’t get shot today.’ We try to laugh it off. To this day, I haven’t been able to tell them about it. They still don’t know the details.”

APD Officer Johnston 05
Arlington police officer Eddie Johnston Paul Moseley

The jury took nearly six hours on Friday to convict McCommon of aggravated assault with a deadly weapon for wounding the Arlington officer.

Had he been convicted of the initial aggravated assault on a peace officer charge, McCommon could have received a life prison sentence. The maximum penalty for the aggravated assault with a deadly weapon charge is 20 years.

McCommon could still face a murder trial in connection with the death of Miles, 17, according to prosecutors.

But because he has no criminal history and has complied with the conditions of his bond, McCommon is eligible to receive probation for this conviction.

“Conner never set out to harm anyone,” his attorney, Deric Walpole, told the jury during his closing arguments. “Conner set out to make 10 or 15 bucks by selling marijuana to someone he didn’t know.”

Sending McCommon to prison, according to Walpole, just makes a bad situation worse.

“He’s not evil,” Walpole said. “He made a mistake and it’s not going to happen again. Nothing like this is ever going to happen again. Grant probation. That makes sense. Sending him to prison when he didn’t intend to harm anybody. That’s wrath. That’s vengeance. Those are the worst parts of us. The best parts of us are forgiveness, compassion.”

The best parts of us are bravery and selflessness, the characteristics of the officers who stood outside McCommon’s door before he sent Johnston to the hospital with a bullet wound, said Tim Rodgers, Tarrant County prosecutor.

If McCommon believed he had acted in self defense when he fatally shot Miles, he should have called the police, Rodgers said.

“His only defense was I didn’t want to get into any trouble,” Rodgers said. “What does that tell you about his character?”

“There has to be justice for the blood that has been spilled by his hand,” Rodgers said.

A small memorial on Creekside Drive in Saginaw where Jordan Miles, 17, died on Saturday. Christian Boschult Star-Telegram

McCommon told police he planned to sell a small amount of marijuana to a girl he met online, but he was met by Miles and two of his friends instead.

The four men climbed into McCommon’s 2006 red Nissan Altima, when Miles pulled a fake gun and the four men began fighting, according to witness testimony.

A gunshot rang out and Miles grabbed McCommon’s real gun and dropped his fake gun in the car, and then stumbled away as his two friends ran, police said.

According to evidence presented by prosecutors, McCommon followed Miles a short distance, beat him and then stood over him yelling: “Where’s my money?” McCommon retrieved his gun from Miles and drove away, according to police.

Less than 48 hours later, when he heard police officers knock incessantly on his apartment door on April 25, 2016, McCommon looked out of the peephole and saw no one, but believed it was friends of the man he had killed come to pay him a visit.

McCommon testified that he partially opened the door, heard someone yell, and then he fired without aiming, hitting Johnston once in the hip. Police never announced that they were at the door, McCommon testified.

“My conduct was reckless,” said Dawn Ferguson, Tarrant County prosecutor. “Those are his own words. If you believe his story that he stuck his arm outside that door and shot wildly. A reasonable, ordinary person would not do that.”

“You can’t trust him on probation,” Ferguson said.

Ex-University of Texas at Arlington student Joel McCommon, 26, is accused of aggravated assault of a peace officer. Arlington Police officer Eddie Johnston was shot on April 25, 2016, while assisting Saginaw police serve a felony murder warrant.

Related stories from Fort Worth Star Telegram