Becoming Benjamin: A teen’s transition from girl to young man
Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton on Tuesday issued an opinion saying that the Fort Worth school superintendent who made headlines for formulating guidelines to accommodate transgender students exceeded his authority. Paxton also said that a portion of the guidelines instructing district employees not to out transgender students to their parents might violate state law.
Citing a part of the Texas education code, Paxton wrote that school district boards of trustees — not superintendents — are required to adopt policies, while superintendents can only implement those policies “by developing administrative regulations.”
Attorney general opinions are not legally binding, and Paxton’s interpretation has no direct legal impact on the Fort Worth district.
The Fort Worth ISD guidelines are in line with a directive from the Obama administration — issued after the guidelines were adopted — that instructed school districts across the country to ensure that transgender students are not discriminated against. Republican Lt. Gov. Dan Patrick requested the opinion three weeks after calling for Fort Worth ISD Superintendent Kent Scribner’s resignation.
Fort Worth ISD’s guidelines instruct district employees to “acknowledge the gender identity that each student consistently and uniformly asserts” and provide necessary accommodations to ensure their safety. Scribner announced he had signed the guidelines, which had been under development for roughly a year, at a meeting of the Fort Worth ISD board on April 26.
The district has indicated that the board of trustees was not asked to vote on the policy because it is an “administrative guideline” — a policy that superintendents can implement without official board approval — that stemmed from a nondiscrimination policy updated in 2011.
To ensure privacy of students, particularly in cases when the student has not disclosed gender identity status to a parent or guardian, Fort Worth ISD’s guidelines include a protection of privacy for transgender students, directing school personnel to only share information about the student’s gender identity and expression on a “need-to-know basis or as the student directs.”
In his opinion, Paxton indicated that portion of the guidelines violates state law to the extent that the guidelines “limit parental access to information about their child and operate to encourage students to withhold information from parents.” Policies dealing with “parental involvement with students’ gender identity choices” must be “addressed” by the school board before they are implemented, he said. He added that the guidelines “relegate parents to a subordinate status.”
FWISD reviewing opinion
In response to Paxton’s opinion, a spokesman for Fort Worth school district said the district’s legal counsel was reviewing the opinion. “She will advise the superintendent as appropriate,” he added.
Scribner has stood by the guidelines and confirmed that he will stay in his post. School board trustees have reiterated that they were in the loop on the policy change with at least two saying they’re surprised the issue had escalated.
Patrick’s ire over the district’s guidelines to accommodate transgender students has played out against a growing national debate over the right of transgender people to decide which restroom they use. The Fort Worth ISD guidelines specify that schools must ensure that students feel safe in their restrooms.
LGBT advocates have said the Fort Worth ISD guidelines are on solid legal ground and have expressed skepticism over concerns about safety related to restrooms. With virtually no evidence of any danger that resulted from transgender-inclusive restroom policies, they insist the fight over restrooms is further stigmatizing transgender people.
On Tuesday, Patrick said the opinion was “a clear and resounding victory for parents.”
“As I said from the beginning, Superintendent Kent Scribner violated the Texas Education Code when he unilaterally adopted his so-called transgender policies without school board approval,” Patrick said. “Today, the attorney general agreed.”