Burgers

The readers’ bracket winner has been there before

Battle of the Burgers: 2017

The fifth Battle of the Burgers has rookies, comeback kids, returning champs and lots of beef. Here's a look at the field for 2017, and the past winners.
Up Next
The fifth Battle of the Burgers has rookies, comeback kids, returning champs and lots of beef. Here's a look at the field for 2017, and the past winners.

This is the Star-Telegram’s fifth Burger Battle, which originated in 2009 as the DFW.com Battle of the Burgers. For the first time, there was a repeat winner in the judges’ bracket.

And for the first time, there was a repeat winner in the readers’ bracket.

The final round was tough, with Nicky D’s in Crowley tangling with Tom’s Burgers & Grill in Arlington. Both are throwbacks, but in different ways: Nicky D’s has “burger joint” written all over it, a roadside stop where part of the charm is the outdoor restrooms, and the foot-pump sinks you use to wash your hands. Tom’s, in a former Denny’s Diner, is all sleek-chrome and soda-fountain feel, especially when you walk in and see the counter area at the entrance.

And while Nicky D’s put up a hellacious fight in the readers’ finale, Tom’s is an experienced campaigner and wound up winning with 53 percent of the final-round vote.

Tom’s won in 2013 with a social-media blitz, a strategy that was echoed in 2017. Owner Tom Jones, the former engineer who launched his burger joint in 2006, told us in 2013: “I worked my butt off, to be honest with you. I did anything and everything I could think of to get the word out.”

Nicky D’s also made a strong social push, getting the word out on its Facebook page and encouraging voters to vote only once per round. But it wasn’t enough to take down the Tom’s machine.

  Comments