January 30, 2014

Is Obama overreaching with his executive orders?

It’s been a fault of both Democratic and Republican presidents.

President Obama says he plans to advance an ambitious policy agenda this year “with or without Congress.”

“I have got a pen and I have got a phone, and I can use that pen to sign executive orders,” the president has said in recent weeks. He echoed the theme in his State of the Union address to Congress this week

Do Obama’s executive orders exceed his constitutional power? Or is he using all of the tools at his disposal in face of congressional opposition?

Joel Mathis

Two words: Unitary executive.

You might not remember those words — Republicans in Congress certainly don’t seem to. They were the name of a theory, advocated by Dick Cheney in particular, under which the George W. Bush administration unilaterally chose to ignore Congress and its legal obligations, pretty much whenever it chose.

A law against warrantless wiretapping? Ignore it. Treaties against torture? Ignore them.

Don’t like the new law Congress passed? Don’t veto it — sign it, but add a “signing statement” explaining why you won’t actually obey it.

All of this happened with the near-total acquiescence of congressional Republicans throughout the Bush administration. (Ron Paul was the exception.)

Much like their love of fiscal austerity and the filibuster, the GOP rediscovered its fidelity to the rule of law with alacrity in 2009, when President Obama took office.

Republicans don’t believe in a constrained, limited presidency. They believe in constraining and limiting Democrats. It’s not the same thing.

This isn’t to let Democrats off the hook. They spent the Bush years complaining about abuses of power and now beg the president to bypass Congress wherever possible. Cynical power-grabbing is a bipartisan exercise.

And yes, the president is among the cynical power-grabbers: “Any President takes an oath to ‘preserve, protect and defend the Constitution of the United States,’ ” he said when he first ran for president, suggesting he would rein in the excesses of the Bush administration. “The American people need to know where we stand on these issues before they entrust us with this responsibility — particularly at a time when our laws, our traditions and our Constitution have been repeatedly challenged by this administration.”

So much for that.

Ben Boychuk

Too many presidents — Republican and Democrat — have stretched the interpretation of their powers to the limit, and sometimes beyond.

In that sense, President Obama is no different from past presidents. But in crucial ways, he has used and abused his powers in ways his predecessors only fantasize about.

Committing American airpower in 2011 to help overthrow Libyan dictator Moammar Gadhafi withoutconsulting Congress was a milestone in presidential overreach.

Obama decided in 2012 that Congress wasn’t doing enough to reform U.S. immigration laws. So he signed an executive order barring the Immigration and Customs Enforcement service from deporting minors and relatives of U.S. service members living in the United States illegally.

The president’s justification was at least somewhat plausible: “prosecutorial discretion” gives him some leeway on enforcement.

But when the president decided to delay his healthcare law’s “employer mandate,” he engaged in nothing less than wholesale lawlessness.

The reason for the delay boils down to cynical political calculation: forcing employers with more than 50 workers to provide health insurance ahead of the 2014 midterm elections would likely disrupt the economy and be bad for Democrats.

Congress has for too long delegated far too much of its power to the executive branch. It’s past time the legislative branch used its authority to hold this president to account, starting with enforcing his ill-conceived healthcare reform law.

Ben Boychuk (bboychuk@city-journal.org) is associate editor of the Manhattan Institute’s City Journal. Joel Mathis (joelmmathis@gmail.com) is associate editor for Philadelphia Magazine.

Related content



Editor's Choice Videos