September 1, 2014

Momentum builds for four-year degrees at community colleges

Opposition to the proposal has been strong in the Legislature.

Since 2003, when South Texas College, Midland College and Brazosport College received permission to offer bachelor’s degrees, several other community colleges have tried to do the same.

Ahead of the 2015 legislative session, momentum seems to be building for other two-year institutions to get a chance to offer four-year degrees.

Opening the door for new bachelor’s degrees in nursing and applied sciences at community colleges is listed as a priority recommendation for the Texas Higher Education Coordinating Board.

In early August, Raymund Paredes, the state higher education commissioner, who previously expressed skepticism about such programs, told legislators he planned to recommend that they be allowed at more institutions.

“I made my recommendation on the basis of trying to create another pathway for poor, nontraditional students in Texas to achieve a baccalaureate degree,” he said.

His recommendation comes on the heels of a study, mandated by a bill that passed during the 2013 legislative session, that found that allowing more community colleges to offer bachelor’s degrees could make it easier to meet work force needs and would increase access to education for would-be students.

The study, by the Rand Corp., a nonprofit research organization, also cited concerns in the higher education community about mission creep at two-year schools and the potential for creating unproductive competition between universities and colleges.

The report offered three options: Do not change the current landscape, allow unrestricted expansion of four-year degrees at community colleges, and allow restricted growth. The study said the choices “necessarily involve difficult trade-offs.”

Paredes, who ultimately recommended the third option, said controls would be tight.

Interested community colleges will have to demonstrate a workforce need for their desired degree program, and to show that the program was not duplicating any others in the region and that the possibility of collaborating with local universities had been exhausted, among other criteria.

Even with the support of the commissioner, the proposal must still get through the Legislature.

Strong opposition

State Sen. Rodney Ellis, D-Houston, filed a bill in the 2013 session that would have allowed expansion of bachelor’s programs in nursing at community colleges. After a significant watering-down, it became the bill that mandated the Rand Corp. study.

“I ran into a buzz saw, a firestorm that was tougher than just about anything I’ve run into,” he said. “I was having challenges even getting a hearing on the bill. To be honest, maybe it was an idea whose time had not come.”

More than 20 states allow at least some community colleges to offer bachelor’s degrees. In California, a bill that would allow them was sent to the governor recently for his signature. “I think the evidence suggests, not only within Texas but around the country, that there is a niche for these kinds of programs,” Paredes said.

Brenda Hellyer, chancellor of San Jacinto College, which cannot offer four-year degrees, said a sudden proliferation of new programs is unlikely.

“It’s not like this is for all community colleges,” she said. “It really is driven by specific needs of a community.”

Shirley Reed, president of South Texas College, said offering bachelor’s degrees for nearly the last decade had not caused the college institution to stray from its mission.

Saying baccalaureate students represent only 2.3 percent of enrollment at the three community colleges in Texas that offer the degrees, she said, “The tail is not wagging the dog.”

Related content



Editor's Choice Videos