With help from Watchdog readers, couple's health coverage problem is solved

By DAVE LIEBER

watchdog@star-telegram.com

Today we look at the wonderful concept of taking ownership of someone’s problem and solving it. Does anyone do that anymore?

Certainly, in the case of Joaquin and Martha Romero of Arlington, nobody did.

Not the human resources department at American Airlines, where Joaquin Romero had retired as a ground crew chief after 30 years.

Not UnitedHealthcare, which improperly rejected his claims for the past three years and kept telling him to contact an insurance company that most likely does not exist.

The only people who took ownership of the Romeros’ problem were Watchdog readers who voted in a poll I held last month to pick their favorite story among 10 suggested topics.

You did what nobody else would do: You cared about their problem and made it priority one.

Too bad nobody cared before now, because their issues could have been resolved three years ago. But that didn’t happen.

When Joaquin Romero retired, he expected that the health insurance offered under his union contract would provide supplemental coverage for expenses not paid by Medicare for him and his wife for the rest of their lives.

But when the couple filed claims with United for the allowed 20 percent unpaid cost, they were always rejected.

"Denial after denial after denial after denial," Martha Romero says. "It’s unbelievable. It’s the biggest problem I’ve ever had."

The reason? United kept telling the Romeros that their secondary insurance was handled by another company, Intercare.

The Romeros could never figure out what Intercare was. I couldn’t find Intercare either.

But try telling that to United’s computer system, which kept reporting incorrect information. Nobody bothered to change it.

"I’m at my wits’ end here," Joaquin Romero told me.

Once we shared the information with American Airlines and United, the insurer found the problem in its system.

The company is now reviewing records and expects to pay the Romeros about three years’ worth of rejected claims. It could total several thousand dollars.

United says the company believes that the phantom insurance company’s listing was based on information provided by one of the Romeros’ doctors. The Romeros say their doctors checked all records and could never find the mistake.

Martha Romero says she refused to quit fighting because she knew she was right. But that’s rare.

Jim Riddlesperger, a political science professor at Texas Christian University, says most consumers don’t fight rejected claims very long. A company can delay making payments, as happened in this case.

"So, obviously, denying claims as a corporate strategy is a way to save money," Riddlesperger says.

Unanswered questions remain, though, about the various people who could have helped the Romeros but didn’t.

Take the human resources representatives at American.

"When I called, they didn’t want to go into the details," Joaquin Romero says. "I asked a young lady, 'Why don’t you get ahold of UnitedHealthcare?’ She said, 'No, you have to do that yourself.’ "

Looking for comments?