Waco life insurance firm accused of systematic fraud
01/03/2012 11:49 PM
01/04/2012 12:09 AM
Waco-based Life Partners Holdings and three of its top executives were accused Tuesday by the Securities and Exchange Commission of "systematically and materially" misleading investors about the life expectancy of people whose life insurance policies it traded.
The scheme inflated the value of the company's stock, according to a suit that the SEC's Fort Worth office filed in federal court in Waco.
Investigators say CEO Brian Pardo sold about $11.5 million of Life Partners stock at inflated prices while having information not available to the public about the company's dependency on short-lifespan estimates.
"Life Partners duped its shareholders by employing an unqualified medical doctor to assign baseless life expectancy estimates to the underlying insurance policies," said Robert Khuzami, director of the SEC's Division of Enforcement.
"This deception misled shareholders into thinking that the company's revenue model was sustainable when in fact it was illusory."
Pardo, 69, denied the accusations, saying: "It is very disappointing that the SEC has chosen to pursue litigation over issues that we believe have no merit and financial presentation issues that we do not believe are material.
"We have always done our best to deliver value to our shareholders and to run an honest and transparent company. We intend to vigorously defend ourselves against these meritless claims."
The federal action could become a political embarrassment to Gov. Rick Perry, who is running for the Republican presidential nomination. Perry's campaign used Pardo's Cessna Citation X business jet and, according to The New York Times, acknowledged underpaying Pardo nearly $23,000 for nine days early in Perry's White House quest.
The SEC filing deals only with Life Partners, which served as a "life settlement" broker -- pairing people who no longer can afford their policy premiums with investors who took fractional interests in the policies. Sometimes policies were bought from companies who had insured key workers but then had little interest in the insurance after the employees left.
"The senior-most executives at Life Partners concealed significant risks to the business, manipulated financial statements with improper accounting, and knowingly profited from their misconduct by executing insider trades based on information that was not available to the public," said David Woodcock, director of the SEC's Fort Worth office.
The three executives were identified as Pardo, counsel Scott Peden and Chief Financial Officer David Martin, the SEC said.
The suit seeks unspecified civil penalties from the three as well as the return of stock trade profits and bonuses from Pardo and Martin.
In 1999, Life Partners hired Donald T. Cassidy, a Reno, Nev.-based oncologist trained in Galveston, to estimate people's life expectancy without having any actuarial education or experience, the complaint alleged.
"Pardo, Peden and Martin were aware that the Cassidy-rendered life expectancy estimates were systematically and materially short," the SEC said.
In a life settlement transaction, the estimate of a person's life expectancy is crucial in figuring the market price that investors would pay. More would be paid for policies of people who have shorter life expectancies since they would get their share of the interest in the death benefit sooner, the SEC complaint said.
The market can be gamed by declaring life expectancies to be shorter than typical industry methodology would.
From fiscal 2007 through the third quarter of 2011, the company misstated net income by prematurely recognizing revenue while understating impairment expense by millions, because they were based on Cassidy's inaccurate analyses, it said.
Cassidy had been instructed to use life expectancy methodology worked up by Dr. Jack Kelly, also of Reno, who was the company's former underwriter and a part owner who "died unexpectedly" in 1999, the SEC said.
Cassidy, a 1974 graduate of the University of Texas Medical Branch at Galveston, got his marching orders during Kelly's funeral, the commission claimed. He was paid $500 per life expectancy analysis, then given an additional $15,000 a month, the SEC said.
By March 2009, Pardo, Peden and Martin "knew, or were reckless in not knowing" that 90 percent of policies reviewed by Cassidy had exceeded the doctor's life expectancy estimate, the SEC stated.
Cassidy made thousands of estimates, which were never reviewed for accuracy, during his decadelong affiliation with the Texas firm, it said. Even when a consultant hired by a potential investor reported to Pardo in 2006 -- seven years into Cassidy's tenure -- that the doctor's figures had not been checked, no action was taken, the SEC said.
Cassidy could not be reached to comment Tuesday night. His answering service said, "Dr. Cassidy doesn't speak to reporters."
Among misleading statements to investors, Pardo said during teleconferences in 2007 and 2008 that Life Partners was delivering "double-digit" returns, the SEC said.
But he knew such returns were impossible even in the best-case scenarios, in which all of those insured die within the company's estimated life expectancy period, the SEC said. Actually, 2,900 insured people had outlived the company's predicted lifespan, it added.
Barry Shlachter, 817-390-7718
Join the Discussion
Fort Worth Star-Telegram is pleased to provide this opportunity to share information, experiences and observations about what's in the news. Some of the comments may be reprinted elsewhere on the site or in the newspaper. We encourage lively, open debate on the issues of the day, and ask that you refrain from profanity, hate speech, personal comments and remarks that are off point. Thank you for taking the time to offer your thoughts.