NBA’s one-and-done rule draws mixed reviews

Posted Monday, Jun. 23, 2014  comments  Print Reprints
More information

Just one look

Here’s a look at some of the top college freshman in Thursday’s NBA Draft:

Joel Embiid, center, Kansas: Recent surgery on his right foot won’t scare off teams.

Jabari Parker, forward, Duke: Can create his own shot, which is a must in today’s NBA.

Julius Randle, forward, Kentucky: Rugged play and a tough mind are his biggest assets.

Andrew Wiggins, forward, Kansas: NBA-ready game with the open-court flair to be a star.

Noah Vonleh, forward, Indiana: Long arms on a long body creates matchup problems.

Have more to add? News tip? Tell us

Donnie Nelson didn’t waste much time voicing his displeasure about players who join the NBA after playing just one year of college ball.

“We’re not in the babysitting business,” the Dallas Mavericks’ president of basketball operations said.

Under terms of the collective bargaining agreement, the NBA allows athletes who are at least one year removed from high school graduation to join its league as early entry draft candidates. But before he retired in February following a 30-year term as NBA commissioner, David Stern attempted to get the National Basketball Players Association to agree that no one can play in the NBA until he’s at least 20 years old.

The issue of one-and-done players can be a contentious bargaining chip if either side opts out of the current CBA in 2017.

“My opinion, in an ideal world, is for guys to have the maturation of a college experience, and I think it’s better for the college product and better for our product if we get players that are more developed and older,” Nelson said. “That being said, there’s always the unique case that has to be addressed.

“But for the most part, for the overall good of college and pro basketball, I think it’s in both of our best interest to have players come in [to the NBA] with more college experience versus less.”

On the front end of the equation, one-and-done players basically deny a college program the chance to develop a young player. On the back end, those players usually aren’t mentally or physically prepared for life in the NBA, which includes a new level of finances, exhausting travel schedules and increased demands of time and attention.

For the players, coming to the league early has a couple primary benefits. Everyone drafted in the first round gets a guaranteed two-year contract that will vary in salary from the top pick, slotted in 2014-15 to earn almost $4.6 million his first season, to the 30th pick, guaranteed $918,000 his first year.

Secondly, the quicker they get to the NBA, the quicker they can get to their second contract. For those who develop into stars, their second contract can be a quantum leap from their rookie deal.

College coaches realize that having an extremely talented player means he is likely to stay for just one season.

“Any time you can get a player that’s good enough to leave [college] after one year, he probably had some success and your team had some success,” Oklahoma State coach Travis Ford said. “I think it’s a tough situation, especially for the coaches trying to develop some chemistry within your team and some continuity.”

The top one-and-dones expected to be chosen in Thursday’s NBA Draft include Duke’s Jabari Parker, Kentucky’s Julius Randle, Indiana’s Noah Vonleh and the Kansas duo of Andrew Wiggins and Joel Embiid. While those players are projected to be successful in the NBA, they are exceptions to the rule.

“I personally would prefer players that come to college, stay two years or three years,” Baylor coach Scott Drew said. “I just think in two years you’re socially and academically able to be more invested and grow more. But whatever the rule is, that’s what we’ll all adjust to.”

Ryan Blake, the senior director of NBA scouting operations, would like for the NBA to get out of the business of adjusting to one-and-done players.

“This is not the company NBA — this is my opinion — that when you have two years to evaluate a player, you bring in a better product,” Blake said.

The most celebrated one-and-done is Kevin Durant, who left Texas after his freshman season and was the No. 2 overall pick by Seattle, now the Oklahoma City Thunder, in the 2007 NBA Draft. But for every Durant, there are plenty of players not prepared for the NBA.

“You’ll have an unbelievable, once-in-a-million Durant franchise player,” Blake said. “But you’re going to have guys that you have to develop, and it takes time.”

Kareem Abdul-Jabbar, the NBA’s all-time leading scorer, also isn’t a fan of one-and-done players.

“I think one-and-done does not work,” Abdul-Jabbar said. “I think basically the NBA needs to raise the age up to 21 or something like that just to make sure that people can make this transition.

“I saw too many immature unprepared people coming straight out of high school — they didn’t have a chance. It wasn’t really a great opportunity for them because their lack of knowledge really worked against them.”

Mavericks free agent point guard Devin Harris, who spent three seasons at Wisconsin before declaring for the draft in 2004, sides with the players who can seek fame and fortune earlier if they bolt to the NBA after one year of college.

“I don’t necessarily blame them, especially the way the NCAA is,” Harris said. “I think it could be a good thing or a bad thing — it just depends on the person. You have certain guys that work out really well and certain guys that struggle. It depends on their maturity level.”

Ford summed up the plight of the college coaches, saying, “We all would like to have some one-and-done players, that’s for sure, if they’re good enough to do it. But at this point, it doesn’t do much good to complain about it. It is the rule. And you’ve got to deal with it.”

Dwain Price, 817-390-7760 Twitter: @dwainprice

Looking for comments?

We welcome your comments on this story, but please be civil. Do not use profanity, hate speech, threats, personal abuse or any device to draw undue attention. Our policy requires those wishing to post here to use their real identity.

Our commenting policy | Facebook commenting FAQ | Why Facebook?

Friday, November 28Full Scoreboard
No games today
Full Scoreboard
Friday, November 28Full Scoreboard
Chicago «109Final | Box
Golden State «106Final | Box
New Orleans91Final | Box
Atlanta «100
Milwaukee «104Final | Box
Dallas1044th Qtr 0:15 | Box
Toronto100TV: FSN-SW, TSN2
LA Clippers974th Qtr 2:25 | Box
Orlando83Final | Box
Indiana «98
New York734th Qtr 1:23 | Box
Oklahoma City105TV: MSG, FSN-OK
Sacramento804th Qtr | Box
San Antonio88TV: CSN-CA, FSN-SW
Phoenix473rd Qtr | Box
Denver66TV: FSN-AZ, Altitude
Memphis61st Qtr 7:14 | Box
Portland15TV: SPSO, CSN-NW
Minnesota 11/28 10:30 PM ET
Full Scoreboard
Week 13Full Scoreboard
Chicago17Final | Box
Detroit «34Gridiron Replay
Philadelphia «33Final | Box
Dallas10Gridiron Replay
Seattle «19Final | Box
San Francisco3Gridiron Replay
San Diego 1:00 PM ET
Baltimore TV: CBS
Cleveland 1:00 PM ET
Buffalo TV: CBS
Tennessee 1:00 PM ET
Houston TV: CBS
Washington 1:00 PM ET
Indianapolis TV: FOX
NY Giants 1:00 PM ET
Jacksonville TV: FOX
Carolina 1:00 PM ET
Minnesota TV: FOX
New Orleans 1:00 PM ET
Pittsburgh TV: FOX
Oakland 1:00 PM ET
St. Louis TV: CBS
Cincinnati 1:00 PM ET
Tampa Bay TV: CBS
Arizona 4:05 PM ET
Atlanta TV: FOX
New England 4:25 PM ET
Green Bay TV: CBS
Denver 8:30 PM ET
Kansas City TV: NBC
Miami 8:30 PM ET
Full Scoreboard
Friday, November 28Full Scoreboard
NY Rangers «3Final | Box
Chicago «4Final | Box
NY Islanders2Final | Box
Washington «5
Winnipeg1Final(OT) | Box
Boston «2
Montreal1Final | Box
Buffalo «2
Detroit «5Final(SO) | Box
New Jersey4
Carolina «4Final | Box
Vancouver «5Final | Box
Ottawa2Final | Box
Florida «3
Edmonton33rd Prd 7:20 | Box
St. Louis3TV: SN-W, FSN-MW
Minnesota33rd Prd | Box
Dallas3TV: FSN-N+, FSN-SW+
Full Scoreboard