A&M’s Manziel, Baylor’s Petty get top Heisman grades

Posted Friday, Nov. 22, 2013  comments  Print Reprints

Have more to add? News tip? Tell us

The 2013 Heisman Trophy race has boiled down to a comparison of quarterbacks, based on multiple straw polls.

Heading into Saturday’s games, two of the five candidates receiving the most attention lead teams from the Lone Star State: Baylor’s Bryce Petty and Texas A&M’s Johnny Manziel, the 2012 Heisman winner. Both have statement opportunities Saturday in road games against ranked opponents.

No. 4 Baylor (9-0, 6-0 in Big 12) plays at No. 10 Oklahoma State (9-1, 6-1) at 7 p.m. in a contest with Big 12 title and BCS bowl implications. No. 12 A&M (8-2, 4-2 in SEC) is at No. 22 LSU (7-3, 3-3) at 2:30 p.m.

Before submitting ballots in December, Heisman voters will listen to coaches, view highlights and examine statistics in efforts to separate Petty and Manziel from their fellow front-runners: Florida State’s Jameis Winston, Oregon’s Marcus Mariota and Alabama’s A.J. McCarron.

Judgments will be made on how much to weigh off-field issues involving Manziel (NCAA infraction) and Winston (implicated in sexual assault; no charges filed) in comparison to their on-field achievements.

To separate the Heisman hopefuls, we sought the counsel of Gil Brandt, former Dallas Cowboys’ vice-president of player personnel (1960-88) and an NFL.com analyst. Brandt, 80, has graded his share of quarterbacks through the years. He offered tips on stats to consider, stats to dismiss and his personal ranking of the five quarterbacks as NFL prospects in order to help the Star-Telegram create an impartial formula to grade candidates.

Who should win it, in Brandt’s estimation?

“If people were truthful and they didn’t know any background of any of the guys off the field, I think Manziel would win it,” Brandt said.

That does not mean Johnny Football is the quarterback Brandt would select first if building an NFL franchise from scratch.

“If you ask the question, ‘Who is the most talented player?’ it’s the Oregon quarterback,” Brandt said. “Mariota is a smaller version of Cam Newton, with better passing skills than Cam had in college. But then you go and ask yourself, ‘If the Aggies didn’t have Manziel, where would they be?’ The guy is just unbelievable with what he does. The question becomes, ‘Do I vote for the best player or do I vote for the guy that’s helping his team win?’”

That Manziel magic, combined with his FBS-best completion rate (73 percent), would give Manziel the lead on a hypothetical Brandt ballot heading into Saturday games. In terms of NFL potential, Brandt rates the five QBs in this order: Mariota, Manziel, Winston, Petty and McCarron.

For purposes of this exercise, we took eight of the 10 quarterback-related statistics tracked in 2013 by the NCAA, mixed in Brandt’s eyeball test and other parameters he suggested, and ranked the candidates.

For the category of “Championships,” we considered BCS, conference or division titles won (McCarron laps the field) as well as potential 2013 titles by QBs from teams (like Baylor) that lead those races at present. We considered only football-related factors in applying our impartial formula to separate Heisman hopefuls. In some categories, there were ties and points were tweaked accordingly.

Then, we tallied the totals. Lowest score wins, just like in golf.

Based on our formula, the 2013 Heisman Trophy front-runner should be Manziel, by a single point over Petty. Winston would be third, three points behind Manziel with ample opportunities to climb before ballots are due after the games of Dec. 7.

Here is the grid used to reach our conclusion, with each quarterback’s initials corresponding to his statistical efforts:

Grading the Heisman hopefuls

CategoryJM (rank)BP JW MM AJM
Pass efficiency 189.6 (3)206.2 (1)195.6 (2)176.2 (4)162.2 (5)
Total offense392.4 (1)346.6 (2)308.3 (4)329.6 (3)221.8 (5)
Completion percentage73.0 (1)65.2 (4)70.9 (2)64.2 (5)67.8 (3)
Yards/completion14.4 (4)19.7 (1)15.9 (2)15.4 (3)12.6 (5)
Points/game23.4 (1)22.7 (2)18.6 (4)20.4 (3)12.6 (5)
Pass yds/game331.3 (2)332.4 (1)293.8 (3)281.9 (4)222.8 (5)
Pass TDs31 (1)24 (4)28 (2)25 (3)21 (5)
Completions/gm23 (1)16.9 (5)18.5 (2)18.3 (3)17.7 (4)
Eyeball test(2)(4)(3)(1)(5)
ChampionshipsN/A (5)Poss. (4)Yes (3)Yes (2)Yes (1)
TDs/INTs31/11 (4)24/1 (2)28/7 (3)25/0 (1)21/5 (5)
4Q wins1 (1)1 (1)N/A (3)N/A (3)N/A (3)
Team record8-2 (5)9-0 (1)10-0 (1)9-1 (4)10-0 (1)

Baylor at Oklahoma State

7 p.m. Saturday

Records: Baylor, 9-0, 6-0 Big 12; Oklahoma State, 9-1, 6-1

TV: WFAA/Ch. 8

Radio: KSKY/660 AM, KCLE/1460 AM

Category Baylor Oklahoma State
Points per game61.240.4
Total offense684.8429.2
Pass offense384.4258.2
Rush offense300.3171
3rd down conv.52.438.9
Points allowed17.419.0
Total defense323373.1
Pass defense190.1239.5
Rush defense132.9133.6
Def. 3rd down conv.32.7%32%

Texas A&M vs. LSU

2:30 p.m. Saturday, Kyle Field

Records: Texas A&M, 8-2, 4-2 SEC; LSU, 7-3, 3-3

TV: KTVT/Ch. 11

Radio: KRLD/105.3 FM

Category Texas A&M LSU
Points per game49.237.9
Total offense578460.4
Pass offense379.2275.6
Rush offense198.8184.8
3rd down conv.52.957.7
Points allowed30.923.5
Total defense454.4353.7
Pass defense243.7200.8
Rush defense210.7152.9
Def. 3rd down conv.36.5%39.2%

Jimmy Burch, 817-390-7760 Twitter: @Jimmy_Burch

Looking for comments?

We welcome your comments on this story, but please be civil. Do not use profanity, hate speech, threats, personal abuse or any device to draw undue attention. Our policy requires those wishing to post here to use their real identity.

Our commenting policy | Facebook commenting FAQ | Why Facebook?

Saturday, September 20Full Scoreboard
Los Angeles7Final | Box
Chicago Cubs «8
Detroit «3Final | Box
Kansas City2
Toronto «6Final | Box
NY Yankees3
Philadelphia «3Final | Box
Arizona1Final | Box
Colorado «5
Boston2Top 4th | Box
Baltimore2@theBallpark | TV: NESN, MASN
Milwaukee0Top 4th | Box
Pittsburgh0@theBallpark | TV: FSN-WI, ROOT-PIT
NY Mets3Top 4th | Box
Atlanta0@theBallpark | TV: WPIX, FSN-S
Seattle1Top 4th | Box
Houston5@theBallpark | TV: ROOT-NW, CSN-HOU
Washington0Bottom 4th | Box
Miami1@theBallpark | TV: MASN, FSN-FL
Cleveland0Bottom 1st | Box
Minnesota0@theBallpark | TV: STO, FSN-N
Chicago WSox0Bottom 4th | Box
Tampa Bay2@theBallpark | TV: CSN-CHI
Cincinnati1Top 4th | Box
St. Louis5@theBallpark | TV: FS1
San Francisco 9/20 8:40 PM ET
San Diego TV: CSN-BA, FSN-SD, MLB Net
Texas 9/20 9:05 PM ET
LA Angels TV: FSN-SW, FSN-W, MLB Net
Full Scoreboard
Saturday, September 20Full Scoreboard
No games today
Full Scoreboard
Week 3Full Scoreboard
Tampa Bay14Final | Box
Atlanta «56Gridiron Replay
San Diego 1:00 PM ET
Buffalo TV: CBS
Tennessee 1:00 PM ET
Cincinnati TV: CBS
Baltimore 1:00 PM ET
Cleveland TV: CBS
Green Bay 1:00 PM ET
Detroit TV: FOX
Indianapolis 1:00 PM ET
Jacksonville TV: CBS
Oakland 1:00 PM ET
New England TV: CBS
Minnesota 1:00 PM ET
New Orleans TV: FOX
Houston 1:00 PM ET
NY Giants TV: CBS
Washington 1:00 PM ET
Philadelphia TV: FOX
Dallas 1:00 PM ET
St. Louis TV: FOX
San Francisco 4:05 PM ET
Arizona TV: FOX
Kansas City 4:25 PM ET
Miami TV: CBS
Denver 4:25 PM ET
Seattle TV: CBS
Pittsburgh 8:30 PM ET
Carolina TV: NBC
Chicago 8:30 PM ET
Full Scoreboard
Saturday, September 20Full Scoreboard
No games today
Full Scoreboard