Lawmakers consider slashing mixed-drink taxes at clubs to promote live music

Posted Friday, May. 03, 2013  comments  Print Reprints

Have more to add? News tip? Tell us

Although the crowd of clubs and concert halls on Austin’s famous Sixth Street is just a few blocks from the state Capitol, the worlds of live music and policymaking seldom meet. But this session, lawmakers are considering subsidizing live music.

House Bill 3095, by state Rep. Mark Strama, D-Austin, would cut in half the tax on mixed beverages for businesses that stage live music at least four nights a week for 45 weeks per year, provided they prove that they will spend the savings putting on concerts.

Strama proposed the bill with his hometown in mind. “Music is as much a part of the Austin economy as oil and gas are part of the Texas economy,” he said. “It’s part of what makes this city so appealing.”

Some club owners and performers say the bill would help at a time when the music industry is suffering. But organizations representing cities and counties around Texas disagree, saying that the decreased tax would rob them of needed revenue and that there is no proof that the savings would be passed on to musicians.

Nearly 200 Texas venues — including more than a dozen in Tarrant County — would probably meet the tax cut requirements, according to the Texas Music Office, an agency financed by the governor’s office. They would have to apply for the status of “live music presenter” each year with the state comptroller’s office.

The Legislative Budget Board, which studies the economic impact of potential legislation, estimated that the bill could cost the state, cities and counties $60 million to $80 million per year.

Strama said that projection was too high for the estimated number of eligible venues, and he is working to get a lower figure before bringing the bill back to a House committee, where it is pending.

In a letter to music professionals urging support for the bill, Terry Lickona, lead producer of the nationally syndicated live music show Austin City Limits, wrote that with the downturn in profits for recorded music, “the industry’s primary business driver” is now live music. But venue owners, he said, face “high startup costs, high taxes and copyright fees,” so they need more incentives to book live acts.

“It’s hard to have a live music venue make money,” said Travis Newman, who books music for The Parish, a downtown Austin bar that regularly presents live music. “Musicians end up being squeezed.”

North Texas impact

But the tax break would be “such a cost to the cities,” said Shanna Igo, deputy executive director of the Texas Municipal League, an advocate for cities.

Among the clubs in Tarrant County that would likely meet the tax cut requirements are Sherlock’s Baker Street Pub & Grill in Arlington, and Button’s, Eddie V’s, Lola’s Saloon, The Aardvark, Thirsty Armadillo and White Elephant Saloon in Fort Worth.

Donald Lee, director of the Texas Conference of Urban Counties, said the tax breaks would be pocketed by the clubs and would not go to musicians.

“We just can’t reconcile ourselves to the idea that live music venues in Texas are threatened by the current tax on alcohol, which there seems to be an insatiable appetite for, no matter what the price,” he said. “They should let local communities do this, rather than a statewide thing.”

The city of Austin has not taken an official position on the bill, but a spokesman said it usually relies on the municipal league to vet bills that affect the city.

Newman, whose club The Parish would probably be approved for the tax break, acknowledged that some venues would probably pocket the extra money. “But the cream rises to the top,” he said, “and bands will know which venues treat musicians well and pass on the savings.”

Staff writer John Gravois contributed to this report.

Looking for comments?

We welcome your comments on this story, but please be civil. Do not use profanity, hate speech, threats, personal abuse, images, internet links or any device to draw undue attention. Our policy requires those wishing to post here to use their real identity.

Our commenting policy | Facebook commenting FAQ | Why Facebook?