Star-Telegram.com

Texas State Board of Education poised for change

Posted Sunday, Jun. 03, 2012

Was anybody talking about Gail Lowe's upset by Sue Melton after Tuesday's Republican primary?

How about Michael Soto's major defeat by little-known Marisa Perez on the Democratic side?

And who noticed Tincy Miller getting back at George Clayton, the guy who pushed her out of office, by getting into a runoff for a chance to replace him and regain the seat?

None of these names mean much to most Texans -- but they should. These folks have been running for places on the 15-member Texas State Board of Education, which sets parameters for what public schoolchildren are supposed to learn, highly influencing the content of textbooks purchased all over the state and beyond.

The board isn't as powerful as it once was, thanks to the Legislature scaling back authority. But the panel still is a major forum for tug-of-wars over explosive social issues, such as how evolution and American history are to be taught and how explicit health textbooks should be about sexually transmitted diseases. Not that those topics should be the focus. But the board has caused furors and drawn national attention for its debates over teaching creationism in public school science classes and its micromanagement of revisions to social studies guidelines to insert conservative ideology.

Observers doing the early scoring are saying the primary results won't change much. But that assessment sounds premature.

All 15 board members have to run this year because voting districts were redrawn to adapt to population shifts reflected in the census. Four seats are open because incumbents chose not to run. Plus, three incumbents were ousted in the primaries. Soto, a Democrat and Trinity University English professor who had run after the brouhaha about social studies guidelines, was beat by Perez, a social worker.

Gail Lowe, a Lampasas Republican who has served for a decade and chaired the board in 2009-11, lost to Melton, a retired teacher. And Clayton, a Richardson educator who had beat longtime board member Miller in the 2010 GOP primary, now is out. Of course, most races for the board won't be decided until November because other candidates, including a few from the Libertarian and Green parties, still are in the running.

Races in the two districts that encompass Tarrant County have been low on drama.

In District 11, which extends from Carrollton west of Weatherford and includes west Fort Worth and parts of southeast and southwest Tarrant County, Republican incumbent Pat Hardy, an instructional specialist in Weatherford, went unchallenged in the primary and will face Libertarian Jason Darr in November.

In District 13, which stretches from Fort Worth across Arlington and covers much of Dallas County, Democratic incumbent Mavis Best Knight, a longtime community volunteer in Dallas, will meet Republican S.T. Russell, who's retired from the Dallas police records department and works in real estate.

What's perhaps the most encouraging result of the various flaps on the board over curriculum and textbook content is that many of the new candidates have teaching experience. Even though some didn't survive the primaries, several are likely to take seats once the general election is decided. And that should bring a different -- and, we have to hope, less-partisan, more educationally sound -- tenor to upcoming discussions over science and social studies books.

Looking for comments?