Average players can someday be NFL stars

Posted Monday, Apr. 23, 2012  comments  Print Reprints
A

Sources: Rivals.com, Sports Illustrated, Star-Telegram archives

Have more to add? News tip? Tell us

When Christian Ponder was a senior, it might have looked like he was a future NFL prospect.

But first, he'd have to be a future college prospect.

And the Colleyville Heritage quarterback had a ways to go before that happened. He was rated only a three-star prospect by Rivals.com, a recruiting tracking web site, as a senior for the Panthers.

But that did not doom his NFL chances. He went on to become the 12th player drafted in last year's NFL draft.

Indeed, a modest star rating as a high school player does not appear to limit the chances of being drafted. Last year, the first round of the NFL draft included 10 three-star athletes, 10 four-star athletes and seven five-star athletes.

Four were two-star athletes.

One did not even play football in high school.

Still, the five-star athlete is rare, and it means something. Six of the first 10 picks were five-star high school players, including the Cowboys' pick at No. 9, offensive tackle Tyron Smith.

A look at last year's draftees and their star rating out of high school:

Pick, team

Name, pos.

College

Stars

1. Carolina

Cam Newton, QB

Auburn

5

Rivals was high on him. Everybody was after his time at Blinn JC.

2. Denver

Von Miller, LB

Texas A&M

4

Aggies picked up a prize who was considering OU and Florida.

3. Buffalo

Marcell Dareus, DT

Alabama

3

Rivals had him only a three-star prospect, perhaps because he was a late qualifier.

4. Cincinnati

A.J. Green, WR

Georgia

5

Speed and hands, evident from a very early stage.

5. Arizona

Patrick Peterson, CB

LSU

5

A no-doubt-about-it star who got away from Sunshine State recruiters.

6. Atlanta

Julio Jones, WR

Alabama

5

Built to be a receiver. Used an official visit on Texas Tech.

7. San Francisco

Aldon Smith, LB/DE

Missouri

3

Forced seven fumbles and blocked a punt as a senior.

8. Tennessee

Jake Locker, QB

Washington

4

Also wanted by Major League Baseball as a pitcher.

9. Dallas

Tyron Smith, OT

USC

5

Size was off the charts. Recruiters amazed themselves projecting his college frame.

10. Jacksonville

Blaine Gabbert, QB

Missouri

5

An elite pro-style QB prospect. Headed to Nebraska before Bill Callahan left.

11. Houston

J.J. Watt, DE

Wisconsin

2

Recruited by Minnesota as a tight end, already 6-5.

12. Minnesota

Christian Ponder, QB

Florida State

3

Colleyville Heritage product rated Texas' 50th-best prospect.

13. Detroit

Nick Fairley, DT

Auburn

3

Recruiters were split on his position, but the size - 6-4, 257 - was clear.

14. St. Louis

Robert Quinn, DE

North Carolina

4

A major high school prospect because of his size and quickness.

15. Miami

Mike Pouncey, C

Florida

4

With twin Maurkice, part of a multi-player Lakeland High haul for Gators in 2007.

16. Washington

Ryan Kerrigan, DE

Purdue

3

Indiana's fourth-ranked recruit, but not a national name.

17. New England

Nate Solder, OT

Colorado

3

At 6-8, had basketball background in high school.

18. San Diego

Corey Liuget, DE/LB

Illinois

4

At 6-3, 260, rated seventh-best prospect at his position.

19. NY Giants

Prince Amukamara, CB

Nebraska

3

Arizonian did not get much attention outside Southwest and Pac-10.

20. Tampa Bay

Adrian Clayborn, DE

Iowa

4

Missouri player of year as senior and four-year letterman in football and basketball.

21. Cleveland

Phil Taylor, DE

Baylor

4

Already at 346 pounds as a high school senior, rated Maryland's sixth-best prospect.

22. Indianapolis

Anthony Castonzo, OT

Boston College

2

Left his Illinois high school for military school in Virginia.

23. Philadelphia

Danny Watkins, G

Baylor

NA

Went to high school in Canada and did not play football. Noticed at California JUCO.

24. New Orleans

Cameron Jordan, DE

California

3

Had 17 sacks as a senior, but rated only 37th defensive end.

25. Seattle

James Carpenter, OT

Alabama

2

Rivals did not rank him on its position, state or national lists.

26. Kansas City

Jonathan Baldwin, WR

Pittsburgh

5

At 6-6, rated fifth-best receiver prospect in the nation.

27. Baltimore

Jimmy Smith, CB

Colorado

3

64th-ranked prospect in California as a senior.

28. New Orleans

Mark Ingram, RB

Alabama

4

Football, track and baseball numbers as a senior are eye-popping.

29. Chicago

Gabe Carimi, OT

Wisconsin

3

A 6-7, 285-pound Wisconsin kid who wanted to go to Wisconsin.

30. NY Jets

Muhammad Wilkerson, DT

Temple

2

Two-time state champion basketball player in high school.

31. Pittsburgh

Cam Heyward, DT

Ohio State

4

Rated the country's 13th-best defensive tackle.

32. Green Bay

Derek Sherrod, OT

Mississippi State

4

OT rated Mississippi's No. 5 overall prospect as a senior.

Looking for comments?

We welcome your comments on this story, but please be civil. Do not use profanity, hate speech, threats, personal abuse, images, internet links or any device to draw undue attention. Our policy requires those wishing to post here to use their real identity.

Our commenting policy | Facebook commenting FAQ | Why Facebook?





Friday, April 18Full Scoreboard
Cincinnati 4/18 2:20 PM ET
Chicago Cubs TV: MLB Net, FSN-OH, WGN
Toronto 4/18 7:05 PM ET
Cleveland TV: SNET, STO
Milwaukee 4/18 7:05 PM ET
Pittsburgh TV: FSN-WI, ROOT-PIT
St. Louis 4/18 7:05 PM ET
Washington TV: FSN-MW, MASN 2
LA Angels 4/18 7:08 PM ET
Detroit TV: FSN-W, FSN-DET
Baltimore 4/18 7:10 PM ET
Boston TV: MLB Network, MASN, NESN
Seattle 4/18 7:10 PM ET
Miami TV: ROOT-NW, FSN-FL
Atlanta 4/18 7:10 PM ET
NY Mets TV: FSN-S, SNY
NY Yankees 4/18 7:10 PM ET
Tampa Bay TV: MLB Net, YES, Sun Sports
Chicago WSox 4/18 8:05 PM ET
Texas TV: CSN-CHI, TXA-21
Minnesota 4/18 8:10 PM ET
Kansas City TV: FSN-N, FSN-KC
Philadelphia 4/18 8:40 PM ET
Colorado TV: CSN-PHI, ROOT-RM
Houston 4/18 10:05 PM ET
Oakland TV: CSN-HOU, CSN-CA
Arizona 4/18 10:10 PM ET
Los Angeles TV: FSN-AZ, SportsNet LA
San Francisco 4/18 10:10 PM ET
San Diego TV: CSN-BA, FSN-SD
Full Scoreboard
Friday, April 18Full Scoreboard
No games today
Full Scoreboard
Full Scoreboard
No games this week
Full Scoreboard
Friday, April 18Full Scoreboard
Montreal 4/18 7:00 PM ET
Tampa Bay TV: CNBC, CBC, RDS, FSN-FL
Eastern Conference Quarterfinals, Game Two. Montreal leads series, 1-0.
Detroit 4/18 7:30 PM ET
Boston TV: NBCSN, TSN, FSN-DET, NESN
Eastern Conference Quarterfinals, Game One.
Dallas 4/18 10:00 PM ET
Anaheim TV: NBCSN, TSN
Western Conference Quarterfinals, Game Two. Anaheim leads series, 1-0.
Full Scoreboard