Steroids cast shadow on baseball's Class of 2013

Posted Thursday, Jan. 12, 2012  comments  Print Reprints
A

Watch video

Baseball's 2013 Hall of Fame class will have some interesting first-time candidates. Three have been major figures during baseball's steroids era. Who will be the first one to get in the Hall?

Have more to add? News tip? Tell us

engel One of the perks of becoming a sports journalist is earning the right to vote this or that player onto an All-Pro team, to an MVP award or even into a Hall of Fame. Candidly, it can be fun.

For those who have earned the right to vote for members of the Baseball Hall of Fame, it has mostly been fun right up through Monday's latest ballot, which landed Reds shortstop Barry Larkin in Cooperstown.

But beginning now and for the foreseeable future, those who vote for baseball's highest honor and the most difficult Hall of Fame to enter in North America now have a burden disguised as a perk.

When the ballot for the Class of 2013 is sent out, Barry Bonds, Roger Clemens, Sammy Sosa and Mike Piazza will be on the list. A carton of syringes should be on it as well.

I don't have a vote, and want zero part of this voting procedure. This vote will demand a no-win judgment call.

Since absolutes in some of these cases are nearly impossible, the best option is not to look at them through a black-and-white lens but rather acknowledge the kaleidoscope that are these ballots.

"I'm not sure 'dread' is the right word. There is going to be some sadness looking at that ballot," said Susan Slusser of the San Francisco Chronicle. She will become the first female president of the Baseball Writers Association of America later this year, and has been voting on the HOF for five years.

"Some of those people in the prime of their careers that you would have thought they would have been in the Hall of Fame for everything they did in the game, and apart from this one thing they should be.... There is no fair way to go about it. There is no guideline at all. I don't plan to vote for anyone that I have good knowledge that cheated the game."

On this latest ballot, former Rangers Juan Gonzalez and Rafael Palmeiro were way down the list. Accept this now: Despite his 3,000 hits and 500 homers, Raffy is never going to get in. Ever.

His critics often dismissed his statistics as a product of the offensive era. Once he was busted, voters who were reluctant to vote for him had their justification to forever say no.

Raffy did the right thing in mostly going away since he left the game, and his good relationships with the media big-hitters in this region pretty much ensured no one locally was going to go after him once it was reported that he failed a drug test.

I would be stunned if the voters in this market whom Raffy had a good rapport with did not vote him in. Relationships can trump a lot in this world.

It will not be enough.

On this latest ballot, Raffy's second time, he received 12.6 percent. That number needs to be 75 percent for induction.

Compared to what is coming, the decision on Raffy is easier than reaching first on an intentional walk.

Even without allegations of steroids, Sosa can easily be excluded based on his record as a one-trick, circus-freak act much the way Mark McGwire has. BTW: This latest ballot, McGwire's sixth, has him with 19.5 percent.

But Bonds, Clemens and even Piazza are far more complex.

Few are going to argue Bonds or Clemens did not belong in the HOF before they were linked to 'roids. Now there is empirical evidence that they used... something.

Piazza, drafted in the 62nd round, was often rumored to be a creation of a syringe full of something that is legal only in Mexico. Or at least we think that, but we don't know that. Slusser plans to vote for Piazza.

But she is a "No" on Bonds and Clemens. Too many documents. Too many prosecution witnesses to suggest that our eyes were not wrong.

There may be a lot of like-minded voters regarding this pair. And spare me the "this is a partial discrimination because Bonds is black" assertion. Boorish jerk is not color specific (see Kent, Jeff).

My gut tells me all three of these men will be inducted into Cooperstown -- eventually.

I can easily envision a large portion of voters waiting years and years to vote "Yes" on this trio as a measure of punishment, since baseball did nothing on its own.

"Bonds and [Alex Rodriguez] were Hall of Famers before there was any evidence of them taking steroids, and that is the heartbreaking part," Slusser said. "Everyone has a different opinion on this. I don't think anyone likes the idea of voting in someone they know took steroids. I think some people will hold their nose and vote them in anyway. Some people say the easiest answer is to vote them all in and act like they didn't take [steroids]."

Slusser calls this situation fluid, and she is open to changing her mind as more evidence becomes available, which it will.

I vacillate on this scenario. One minute I say vote them in, and put in Pete Rose with an asterisk. The next minute I say keep them all out.

A vote that was once fun is now just a burden.

Mac Engel, 817-390-7697

Twitter: @MacEngelProf

Looking for comments?

We welcome your comments on this story, but please be civil. Do not use profanity, hate speech, threats, personal abuse or any device to draw undue attention. Our policy requires those wishing to post here to use their real identity.

Our commenting policy | Facebook commenting FAQ | Why Facebook?





Tuesday, October 21Full Scoreboard
San Francisco «7Final | Box
Kansas City1
110th World Series, Game One. San Francisco leads series, 1-0.
Full Scoreboard
Tuesday, October 21Full Scoreboard
Houston85Final | Box
Miami «90
Indiana89Final | Box
Minnesota «107
Utah «105Final | Box
Oklahoma City91
Portland «93Final | Box
Denver75
Phoenix «114Final(OT) | Box
LA Lakers108
LA Clippers107Final | Box
Golden State «125
Full Scoreboard
Week 8Full Scoreboard
Thursday
San Diego 8:25 PM ET
Denver TV: CBS/NFL Network
Sunday
Detroit 9:30 AM ET
Atlanta TV: FOX
Seattle 1:00 PM ET
Carolina TV: CBS
Baltimore 1:00 PM ET
Cincinnati TV: CBS
Miami 1:00 PM ET
Jacksonville TV: CBS
St. Louis 1:00 PM ET
Kansas City TV: FOX
Chicago 1:00 PM ET
New England TV: FOX
Buffalo 1:00 PM ET
NY Jets TV: CBS
Minnesota 1:00 PM ET
Tampa Bay TV: FOX
Houston 1:00 PM ET
Tennessee TV: CBS
Philadelphia 4:05 PM ET
Arizona TV: FOX
Oakland 4:25 PM ET
Cleveland TV: CBS
Indianapolis 4:25 PM ET
Pittsburgh TV: CBS
Green Bay 8:30 PM ET
New Orleans TV: NBC
Monday
Washington 8:30 PM ET
Dallas TV: ESPN
Full Scoreboard
Tuesday, October 21Full Scoreboard
San Jose3Final | Box
Boston «5
NY Rangers «4Final(OT) | Box
New Jersey3
Toronto «5Final | Box
NY Islanders2
Detroit1Final(OT) | Box
Montreal «2
Arizona3Final(SO) | Box
Nashville «4
Carolina1Final | Box
Winnipeg «3
Philadelphia0Final | Box
Chicago «4
Vancouver3Final | Box
Dallas «6
Florida «4Final(OT) | Box
Colorado3
Tampa Bay «2Final(OT) | Box
Calgary1
Full Scoreboard